When it comes to “MLB The Show 25,” one of the most essential and exciting aspects of the game is its pitcher ratings. These ratings determine the mlb the show stubseffectiveness, style, and overall gameplay experience of pitchers in the game. In this article, we’ll be taking an in-depth look at the top 10 pitchers in The Show 25.
1. Gerrit Cole – SP (New York Yankees)
Arguably one of the most dominant pitchers in MLB The Show 25, Gerrit Cole's fastball is a force to be reckoned with. A high 90s fastball paired with his slider and curveball offers the ideal mix of power and control. On the game, Cole is a go-to ace for those looking to dominate the mound, and his high stamina ensures he can pitch deep into games without losing effectiveness.
In real life, Cole has been a consistent Cy Young contender, and this success translates seamlessly into The Show 25. With a 99 overall rating in the game, he sits at the pinnacle of pitching.
2. Jacob deGrom – SP (Texas Rangers)
In The Show 25, Jacob deGrom is as close to perfection as you can get. With a fastball that reaches triple digits and a devastating slider that breaks sharp, deGrom has been a fan favorite for years. His ability to strike out batters is unmatched, and his pitch movement and velocity make him nearly untouchable when he's on.
Even though deGrom’s real-life injuries have slowed him down at times, his digital counterpart remains a nightmare for hitters in the game. His high 90s ratings in both K/9 and velocity make him a standout choice for players looking to rack up strikeouts in a hurry.
3. Sandy Alcántara – SP (Miami Marlins)
Sandy Alcántara is a true workhorse, and his stamina rating is one of the highest in the game. Known for his ability to pitch complete games in real life, Alcántara’s virtual version in The Show 25 reflects that durability.
He also brings an electric repertoire, including a devastating sinker that dives through the strike zone and a sharp slider that has batters swinging through thin air. His 99 stamina, combined with a mid-90s fastball, makes him a great choice for players who value endurance and pitch consistency throughout a game.
4. Corbin Burnes – SP (Milwaukee Brewers)
With his pinpoint control and filthy pitch movement, Corbin Burnes is another top-tier pitcher in The Show 25. Known for his 2021 Cy Young win in real life, Burnes’ cutter is his calling card in the game, as it fools batters time and time again. His ability to induce weak contact, along with his high strikeout rate, gives him elite status in the game.
In The Show 25, Burnes’ control ratings are particularly impressive, allowing players to paint the corners with ease. His ability to make batters chase pitches out of the zone makes him one of the most effective pitchers in the game.
5. Max Scherzer – SP (New York Mets)
The veteran ace Max Scherzer has had a long and illustrious career, and in The Show 25, his age has not dulled his effectiveness. Scherzer’s slider is one of the nastiest pitches in the game, and his 99 overall rating reflects his continued dominance. His velocity, though not quite as high as it once was, remains solid, and his deep pitch mix keeps batters guessing.
Scherzer’s high K/9 ratings make him a great pitcher for players who like to rack up strikeouts, and his ability to get key outs in clutch moments adds to his value in high-pressure situations.
6. Shohei Ohtani – SP/DH (Los Angeles Angels)
Shohei Ohtani is an anomaly, a two-way player in both real life and in The Show 25. As a pitcher, his fastball touches the high 90s, and his slider is tough to pick up. His unique skill set and versatility make him one of the most valuable players in the game. The 99 overall rating for Ohtani as a pitcher reflects his ability to dominate on the mound with his elite velocity and pitch movement.
Ohtani is a two-for-one deal in the game, giving players a tremendous advantage with his ability to pitch, hit, and serve as a key player in the lineup.
7. Justin Verlander – SP (New York Mets)
Despite being in the later stages of his career, Justin Verlander is still one of the top pitchers in The Show 25. His fastball, while not as overpowering as it once was, is still one of the most dominant pitches in the game. His curveball and slider are both incredibly effective at generating strikeouts, and his overall pitch repertoire gives him the tools to neutralize any offense.
Verlander’s clutch performances, particularly in playoff scenarios, are reflected in his in-game stats, and he’s a great choice for players who want an experienced, battle-tested ace to lead their pitching staff.
8. Clayton Kershaw – SP (Los Angeles Dodgers)
When it comes to control and command of the strike zone, Clayton Kershaw is one of the best in the game. His curveball and slider are arguably two of the best off-speed pitches ever to be thrown in MLB history, and in The Show 25, these pitches make him a nightmare for opposing hitters. His 99 control rating makes him a master of painting the corners and generating weak contact.
Though his velocity may have dipped in recent years, Kershaw’s intelligence and craftiness are on full display in the game, where he remains a top-tier pitcher with incredible finesse.
9. Walker Buehler – SP (Los Angeles Dodgers)
Walker Buehler is a rising star in the MLB, and his abilities are well-represented in The Show 25. His four-pitch mix allows him to keep hitters off balance, and his fastball, combined with his curveball, changeup, and slider, makes him effective against both lefties and righties.
Buehler’s 95-98 mph fastball, paired with exceptional control, gives players confidence when facing even the toughest hitters. His stamina and K/9 ratings make him an appealing choice for players who like to get strikeouts without sacrificing innings.
10. Zack Wheeler – SP (Philadelphia Phillies)
Closing out the top 10 list is Zack Wheeler, another pitcher with exceptional stuff. His high-velocity fastball and devastating slider give him the tools to get batters out quickly. Wheeler’s control is solid, and his movement on his pitches is excellent, making him a reliable choice in both real-life MLB and The Show 25.
Wheeler may not have the same notoriety as some of the other pitchers on this list, but his consistent performance and ability to dominate in various situations make him a key asset in the game.
Conclusion
The top 10 pitchers in The Show 25 are some of the best to ever play the game. From strikeout artists like deGrom and Cole to craft masters like Kershaw and Scherzer, there’s a pitcher for every type of player in The Show 25. Whether you’re looking for raw power, pinpoint control, or devastating off-speed stuff, these pitchers offer something for every style of play.
Stay tuned for future articles that will break down more strategies, pitching mechanics, and how to get the most out of your ace in MLB The Show 25.
